The Rise and Fall and Rise of Pitmaster Ed Mitchell

Link to web version

Monk: Pitmaster Ed Mitchell is in a curious spot these days. His name is in many ways synonymous with eastern North Carolina whole hog barbecue and his reach in the barbecue world is unmatched by few, but he hasn’t operated a barbecue restaurant in almost 10 years.

In this episode of the Southern Foodways Alliance’s Gravy podcast, North Carolina native Wilson Sayre recaps Mitchell’s story from starting to cook pigs at his parent’s grocery store in Wilson, NC in the wake of his father’s passing to that restaurant getting shut down for failing to pay taxes tax (with Mitchell spending time in jail) to partnering in opening The Pit in Raleigh and eventually the opening and closing of his short-lived Durham restaurant Ed Mitchell’s ‘Cue. Along the way, Ed brought on his son Ryan as a business partner to help him with his business decision making.

The Mitchell’s latest venture with restaurateur Lou Moshakos is called The Preserve and was set to open in 2020 (which was to be Raleigh’s “Year of Barbecue”) before getting sidetracked by the COVID-19 pandemic. Unfortunately, this episode is light on solid details for that restaurant, only saying that it is set to open “this spring” (though the episode was released May 22). But of course we’re starting to get into the summer months with little in the way of updates and The Preserve website doesn’t have much more information, only stating that “2023 is our year.”

Unfortunately, it seems as if Ed Mitchell is once again going to have to do it the hard way. All of us North Carolinians will be rooting hard for him.

Description: Ed Mitchell’s name has come to be synonymous with Eastern North Carolina wood-smoked whole-hog barbecue. From Wilson, North Carolina, he grew up smoking hogs and has tried to continue that tradition, using old techniques and traditionally farm-raised pigs.

But almost since the start, Ed Mitchell’s barbeque journey has not been a straight line—business relationships, racism, and smoke have all shaped his rollercoaster ride.

“Horn Barbecue” Joins Other Notable Black Barbecue Books

Not that we’re anywhere close to being qualified enough to evaluate books but more so as a public service announcement we will periodically discuss barbecue and barbecue-related books.

Monk: Matt Horn first rose to barbecue prominence in 2016 after a series of pop-ups in the Bay Area of California, taking cues from Texas barbecue, the American South, and the Bay Area while attempting to create his own style of barbecue called “West Coast barbecue.” He parlayed the success of those pop-ups and his social media presence into a brick and mortar store in West Oakland, which he opened in 2020. And it wasn’t long before the awards followed: Food & Wine Best New Chef in 2021, Esquire’s Best New Restaurants in 2021, a Bib Gourmand from Michelin, and last but not least, a James Beard Award Nomination in 2022.

Also in 2022, Horn released his first book simply titled “Horn Barbecue” solely credited to him. With a foreword by Adrian Miller and blurbs from Miller, Aaron Franklin, Rodney Scott, and David Chang it surely placed him in esteemed company within the barbecue world.

After the short foreword by Miller where he details how his initial visit to taste Horn Barbecue was delayed due to to the pandemic (which explains why Horn wasn’t included in Miller’s 2021 book “Black Smoke”), Horn spends the next 10 or so pages telling his barbecue journey from his grandmother’s backyard to his acclaimed pop ups to finally opening up his restaurant in West Oakland.

Unfortunately, from there it follows what has become the standard template for a barbecue book these days: a section on the basics of barbecue detailing smokers and woods with tips on smoking before turning to a fairly standard set of recipes for proteins, sides, sauces, rubs, and desserts. Horn does write up a short intro for each recipe but there is no real compelling information after the barbecue journey ends on page 31.

The original Horn Barbecue restaurant location suffered a fire last fall before closing permanently this spring, but he has since reopened Horn Barbecue inside his throwback burger restaurant Matty’s Old-Fashioned. Horn has also teased a future concept called Horn Barbecue Shop which will be next door to his chicken restaurant Kowbird. As of this writing I don’t see any further information on this concept.

“Horn Barbecue” joins other books in recent years that have given voice to a historically underappreciated player in the barbecue field: “Black Smoke” by Adrian Miller in 2021, “Rodney Scott’s World of BBQ” by Rodney Scott and Lolis Eric Elie also in 2021, “Bludso’s BBQ Cookbook,” by Kevin Bludso in 2022, and more recently2023’s “Ed Mitchell’s Barbeque” by Ed and Ryan Mitchell with Zella Palmer. For me, the additional black voice in barbecue is always a welcome one even if this book itself is not quite from essential to add to your shelf.

Texas BBQ Perfection at Kreuz Market

Monk: Kreuz Market has been a fixture in downtown Lockhart, Texas ever since Charles Kreuz Sr. purchased a meat market from Jesse Swearingen in 1900 and renamed it. In this video, Trey’s Chow Down visits Kreuz and gives a short video tour before chowing down on beef rib, brisket, sausage, chicken, and their comically large pork chop.

Description: A Texas BBQ legend since 1875 in Lockhart, Texas

Mike D’s BBQ in Durham is North Carolina’s Best New Barbecue Restaurant

Monk: In East Durham, NC, Mike De Los Santos started doing barbecue sauces and rubs that mixed Hispanic and black flavors as a hobby but then a family tragedy refocused him to eventually open a brick and mortar restaurant called Mike D’s BBQ Smokehouse. Last December, his wood-smoked barbecue joint earned Best New North Carolina Barbecue from Eater Carolinas.

Description: Mike De Los Santos brings his award-winning barbecue and rubs to a brick-and-mortar destination in East Durham.